Showing posts with label Sean Marshall. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sean Marshall. Show all posts

5.08.2008

Didn't think this was a post we would have to do, but...

...who should be in the starting rotation right now for the Cubs?


Your choices:

Carlos Zambrano
Ted Lilly
Rich Hill
Ryan Dempster
Jason Marquis
Sean Marshall
Jon Lieber
Sean Gallagher
Other

My opinion:

1) Zambrano (given)
2) Lilly (recovering)
3) Dempster (run support or for real?)
4) Marquis (streaky)
5) Marshall (deserving)

I prefer Lieber as the long reliever. He's a veteran and understands the role. I don't feel comfortable bringing Hill back yet, or giving Gallagher the shot yet. My thought: let's see if Marshall can eat up some innings.

4.27.2008

'How I Met Your Mother' creators must be Cub fans...

On the CBS sitcom "How I Met Your Mother," three of the five main characters are named Ted, Lily, and Marshall.

My wife is convinced that the creators are baseball fans. Specifically, she thinks they are fans of Ted Lilly and Sean Marshall.

(Any chance Aramis Ramirez's real first name is 'Barney?')

She also loved that the Cubs have a player named Pie. She was disappointed, though, to hear it isn't pronounced like the tasty dessert.


3.30.2008

Pignatiello makes roster, biggest surprise of spring

Fair to say the one big surprise of spring training for the Cubs would have to be that Carmen Pignatiello has made the 25-man roster and will start the season in the bullpen. Sadly, that means Sean Marshall was optioned out to Iowa. At least he'll get to start full-time down there.

Also gone is Matt Murton. The Cubs really do treat him like a red-headed stepchild. All he does when he comes up is hit like crazy, but because he can't play centerfield, he always gets shuffled back and forth between Chicago and Iowa.

(And, by the way, I hope Pignatiello changes his number now that he's made the squad. Pitchers don't wear numbers in the 60s. Offensive lineman do. It's bad enough that Bob Howry trots out wearing No. 62. Let's not have too people wearing lousy numbers).

Here's the entire roster:

PITCHERS (12 + 2 D.L.):
21-Jason Marquis, RHP
22-Kevin Hart, RHP
30-Ted Lilly, LHP
32-Jon Lieber, RHP
34-Kerry Wood, RHP
37-Angel Guzman, RHP (60-day DL)
38-Carlos Zambrano, RHP
43-Michael Wuertz, RHP
46-Ryan Dempster, RHP
47-Scott Eyre, LHP (15-day DL)
49-Carlos Marmol, RHP
53-Rich Hill, LHP
62-Bob Howry, RHP
63-Carmen Pignatiello, LHP

CATCHERS (2):
18-Geovany Soto
24-Henry Blanco

INFIELDERS (7):
2-Ryan Theriot
5-Ronny Cedeno
7-Mark DeRosa
16-Aramis Ramirez
17-Mike Fontenot
25-Derrek Lee
33-Daryle Ward

OUTFIELDERS (4):
1-Kosuke Fukudome
9-Reed Johnson
12-Alfonso Soriano
20-Felix Pie

3.28.2008

Thoughts on the roster...

The final 25 is starting to take shape. Here's what we've learned in the last few days:

* Mike Fontenot and Ronny Cedeno will likely both make the team
* Eric Patterson and Matt Murton probably won't
* Reed Johnson will be on the roster, mostly because he can play all three OF positions
* Alex Cintron's been released
* Kevin Hart has virtually sewn up a spot in the 'pen
* Sean Marshall and Carmen Pignatiello are still duking it out for the final relief role

Thoughts:

* I don't see Fontenot sticking. Love the guy, but think he's overmatched by good pitching. And it will show.
* Cedeno surprised me. I'd still prefer his success made him more valuable as trade bait, but he might be able to help this team.
* Murton deserves a shot somewhere else.
* Patterson is a year away from being a starter, but he's got talent.
* Cintron will catch on somewhere. He just picked the wrong team to try and be a utility infielder with.
* I think the bullpen may be a major strength. I loved Kerry Wood and Carlos Marmol's stuff this spring. Bob Howry will wake up. Jon Lieber's great in long relief and I think Marshall can be too. Maybe Hart, Michael Wuertz and Scott Eyre can help too. But these are quality pitchers.

3.24.2008

Decisions, decisions...

It's official.

Ryan Dempster = No. 3 starter
Jason Marquis = No. 5 starter
Kerry Wood = closer
Carlos Marmol = one of the game's best set-up men
Jon Lieber = long reliever
Sean Marshall = likely screwed and heading to AAA

Thoughts: Fine with Marquis. Hopeful for Wood (but not counting on him to stay healthy; quit doing that long ago). Concerned about Dempster. Sympathetic for Marshall. Thinking Lieber got the shaft.

3.22.2008

Ponderings...

* Why did Sean Marshall's name seemingly vanish from the starting rotation battle? It mysteriously went from Lieber-Marquis-Dempster-Marshall to Lieber-Marquis-Dempster, even though Marshall didn't pitch badly. Did I miss a quote from Lou where he said Marshall was out. Or was the storyline just easier to maintain when it was three pitchers instead of four?

Kid deserves better.

* Does it feel to anyone else like the Orioles are holding the Cubs hostage on this Brian Roberts deal, asking for more and more and more until Jim Hendry's head explodes? 'Cause that's how I see it.

* Mark DeRosa's one of my favorites. But he seems to not grasp that Roberts is an upgrade for the Cubs, not only at Mark's position, but by the way he realigns the lineup (allowing Theriot to bat lower in the order, where he belongs; allowing Soriano to bat in the heart of the order, where he belongs).

* Proof you can't believe everything you read on the 'net. Although, knowing Z, it's not too much of a stretch...

3.03.2008

Observations From The Ballpark

Took in the spring training games against the Giants on Sunday (an 8-6 Chicago loss) and the Mariners on Monday (a 6-5 Cubs' victory). Here's what I came away with:

Offense:
Not bad, considering they played without Aramis Ramirez and Alfonso Soriano (and Derrek Lee only had a couple of at-bats on Sunday).

Felix Pie homered Sunday, Alex Cintron and Ryan Theriot each had a couple hits over the two-day span and a number of the prospects had big days on Monday. But the biggest concern was a failure to get the 'big hit;' way too many stranded baserunners.

Defense:
Pretty good for the most part, minus Sam Fuld getting handcuffed Sunday by a line drive. I swear he came within inches of tearing his knee up.
Was most impressed by the catchers (Geovany Soto and Koyie Hill each threw out base-stealers) and Kosuke Fukudome (who made an incredible catch up against the wall and showed off a laser arm).

Pitching:
Three potential 2008 starters hurled in the two-game span: Ted Lilly, Jon Lieber and Sean Marshall. Lilly and Marshall each had trouble locating their pitches, but still impressed me. Lilly, flat-out, has balls. He exudes the 'here it is, hit it' mentality that I love. And Marshall twice pitched himself out of jams and showed some pluck. Lieber was his typical self: he challenged hitters. That style produced a speedy 1-2-3 inning in the first, prompting the woman behind me to say "Wow, that was a really quick inning" (you'll see a lot of them with Lieber, the anti-Trachsel). But the M's t'ed off on Lieber in the second and he gave up two runs.

Impressed me:

Jake Fox and Matt Murton. Both these guys seem to always hit the ball hard somewhere. Murton is a valuable corner outfielder and Fox deserves a shot to be the second catcher.

Alex Cintron has more pop in his bat than I expected and is solid in the infield. He could prove to be a valuable reserve.

Depressed me:

The baserunning on Monday was horrendous. Twice (twice!) a runner at second base got thrown out at third on a ground ball in the infield. It's called running yourself out of a big inning and it's a baseball sin.


Bob Howry was just brutal. He entered the game in the ninth on Monday with a 6-2 lead. He finished off the game, but not before giving up five straight hits and letting the M's cut the lead to one. I'm hoping this was an aberration, but he certainly didn't help his cause in the battle for the closer position.

And as bad as Howry was on Monday, Neal Cotts was just as bad on Sunday. The Giants lit him up like a neon sign on the Las Vegas strip. His fastball looked flat. If Lou Pinella wants to carry two lefties in the 'pen (Scott Eyre and ?), he might have to look in a different direction.

Intrigued me:

Jeff Samardzija has a seriously live arm. He looked very sharp in his two innings on Monday. Very impressed with his velocity and stuff.


Ronny Cedeno was in the leadoff spot on Monday and played all nine innings in centerfield. And, surprisingly (as you might have guessed, I'm not a huge Cedeno guy), he wasn't that bad. He had three hits (hit the ball hard four out of five times up) and didn't embarass himself in the outfield. I said earlier that I thought Fuld or Patterson would make this team as a back-up in centerfield, leaving Cedeno, Mike Fontenot and Alex Cintron to battle for the last roster spot. Now I think it's possible two of the latter three make the club, while Fuld and Patterson both get sent to AAA.

(But, for as well as Cedeno played on Monday, he still got picked off in a typical Ronny-Cedeno-bonehead-move).

Concerned me:

Was walking into the ballpark on Sunday and overheard hitting coach Gerald Perry lamenting that "everyone was trying to get out of the lineup." Minutes later, the PA announcer told us Soriano was scratched with a finger injury. We all know about Mark DeRosa's health concerns and there was no sign of A-Ram. I know these guys don't need too much work in the spring, but I don't want the team to be walking wounded.


I love Fukudome. He has a great eye at the plate, great range in the outfield and, honest to God, reminds me of Spider-Man. Don't know why, but that's what comes to mind. Yet, I don't think he's the right choice for the No. 3 spot in the line-up. He's far more similar to Ichiro than Hideki Matsui. He's a guy who can put the ball in the play and leg out some singles, but I don't see gap-to-gap power. He's far more suited for the No. 2 hole. And if he's not there, I worry we'll lose out on some runs.

2.28.2008

Marquis, Lieber are fan favorites...

A poll on the Cubs' official team site asks which combo should fill out the starting rotation, joining Zambrano, Lilly and Hill:

Lieber & Dempster
Lieber & Marquis
Lieber & Marshall
Dempster & Marquis
Dempster & Marshall
Marquis & Marshall

As of 10:34 p.m. (MST), with 15,777 votes, the results looked like this:

Lieber & Dempster 17%
Lieber & Marquis 28%
Lieber & Marshall 20%
Dempster & Marquis 11%
Dempster & Marshall 7%
Marquis & Marshall 17%



Obviously the largest group of people agreed with my post here...

And interestingly, if you add up the percentages for each pitcher's possibilities in the poll (i.e. Lieber's total when adding his percentage when combined with Dempster and Marquis and Marshall), you get these results:

Lieber: 65%
Dempster: 35%
Marquis: 56%
Marshall: 44%

What can we learn? Cub fans don't like Canadians.

Sorry, Dempster.

2.18.2008

Lilly, Z, Hill...and who?


The status of the starting rotation can be split in half. One half: certain. The other half: very uncertain.

Certain:

#1: Carlos Zambrano
#2: Ted Lilly
#3: ?
#4: Rich Hill (the Cubs third-best starter, but Lou Pinella has said he wants to break up the lefties
#5: ?

Analysis:

* Pinella has said he wants the #3 starter to be a right-hander. So it will likely come down to Jon Lieber, Ryan Dempster, and Jason Marquis. I'd prefer Lieber, who has consistently shown he can throw strikes and keep his team in games. Marquis's history of an inflated ERA frightens me and Dempster's return to the starting rotation (where he was never terribly successful anyway) just doesn't make sense to me.

* Add lefty Sean Marshall to the mix at the #5 spot in the rotation. I'm split here between him and Marquis. While I think Marshall is the better pitcher, Marquis has found a way to win double-digit games for most of his career (15, 13, 14, 12 wins over the last four seasons). So, I'll stick with Marquis and pray the wind isn't blowing out at Wrigley.

Tentatively (reserving the right to change my plea after spring training), I suggest: Z, Lilly, Lieber, Hill, Marquis.

2.16.2008

The need for Roberts...


Trade rumors continue to swirl regarding Brian Roberts. The Orioles second baseman, who recently admitted to using steroids in 2003, has been coveted by the Cubs the entire off-season.

While I don't think GM Jim Hendry should give up an elite prospect for Roberts (Felix Pie, Tyler Colvin), I do think Roberts would make a tremendous addition to the team, and I'd be willing to give up Sean Gallagher, Ronny Cedeno, and even Sean Marshall to get him.

Mostly, I think Roberts would be an ideal lead-off hitter, allowing Lou Pinella to shift Alfonso Soriano down to the middle of the order where he belongs.

Consider: Roberts on-base percentage last year was .377 and he hit .290. Soriano's on-base was .337 while hitting .299. Roberts drove in 57 runs on just 12 homers. Soriano drove in just 70 runs on 33 homers.

Get Roberts to the top of the order where he'll get on-base more often than Soriano. Get Soriano to the middle of the order so his power won't be wasted (getting just 70 RBIs out of 33 home runs is a waste).

Soriano will just have to learn to hit in the No. 5 spot. I'm sure he can.