'A Large Regular' weighs in with his All-Disappointment Team...
Comparing his version with Holy Cowbell's:
Catcher -- We agree on Victor Martinez and his homerless year
First Base -- We said Travis Hafner. He said Richie Sexson.
I think one of his commenters had it correct, pointing out that Sexson's whole career has been a disappointment, so how could this year be any different. (Note: He had Travis Hafner as his most disappointing designated hitter).
Second Base -- We said Robinson Cano. He said Freddy Sanchez.
I tend to think Sanchez's batting title was a fluke, while Cano is the real thing. So, for Cano to be struggling, it's a much bigger disappointment.
Shortstop -- We agree on Troy Tulowitki's sophomore slump.
Third Base -- We agree on Ryan Zimmerman not living up to potential.
Outfield -- We said Andruw Jones, Eric Byrnes and Gary Sheffield. He said Curtis Granderson, Delmon Young and Gary Sheffield.
I'm stunned that he left Jones off his list. Jones would be the captain of this team. And I'm inclined to wait on Granderson; he had a hand injury, which takes awhile to recover from. Come the end of the season, I don't think he'll be such a disappointment.
Pitcher -- We said Justin Verlander and Aaron Harang. He said Roy Oswalt and C.C. Sabathia.
He split his into left-handed and right-handed starting pitchers, so we agree with Sabathia (he was our honorable mention, along with Erik Bedard). And, while I'll stick with Verlander, I don't disagree that Oswalt's been a disappointment. I think he's on the backside of his career and falling fast.
Closer -- We said Eric Gagne. He said J.J. Putz.
We put Putz as the second most-disappointing closer. But no one can top the plumber from Milwaukee.


